Welcome to our new website!


June 1, 2022

S10 Ep2: Making a Predator

The last time we saw Brent, he was at the AMC IMAX theater, on the east side of Noblesville, Indiana. A sophomore at Ball State University, Brent had arranged to meet an underaged girl in for a movie that afternoon. …

Episode page
May 25, 2022

S10 Ep1: Making a Predator

Our story begins with a man walking into a movie theater in Noblesville, Indiana – 22-year-old Brent Allred. Brent is shy, self-effacing, and junior at nearby Ball State University. He’s meeting a woman here, or rather a girl...

Episode page
May 18, 2022

S9 Ep6: Serial Killer H.H. Holmes

I have so many questions about Holmes and we are sure you do too, so in this episode we will be answering some of them. Let’s start with Why Did Holmes Kill Pitezel? Holmes had written to Mrs Pitezel from …

Episode page
May 11, 2022

S9 Ep5: Serial Killer H.H. Holmes

Holmes was sentenced to hanging for the murder of Benjamin F Pitezel on May 7th 1986, when he was aged just 34 years old. While there was a lot of circumstantial evidence that he also murdered Alice, Nellie and Howard …

Episode page
May 4, 2022

S9 Ep4: Serial Killer H.H. Holmes

Of course, nobody in the District Attorney’s office believed a word that came out of Holmes mouth, so the investigation to find the children continued in earnest. It was going to be like finding a needle in a haystack, but …

Episode page
April 27, 2022

S9 Ep3: Serial Killer H.H. Holmes

Frank Geyer, started his career with the City of Philadelphia Police Department on 6 May 1876 as a patrolman. In January 1888 he was promoted to detective and in 1894 was assigned a new case, involving suspected insurance fra...

Episode page
April 20, 2022

S9 Ep2: Serial Killer H.H. Holmes

Holmes settled in comfortably in Chicago, he was well liked, he was charismatic, intelligent and fun to be around, nobody had a bad word to say about him. He worked hard and saved his money, his family was an inconvenience …

Episode page
April 13, 2022

S9 Ep1: Serial Killer H.H. Holmes

Just a month after the beginning of the American Civil War, on May 16th, 1861, arguably the world's most infamous serial killer was born in Gilmanton, New Hampshire. In this episode Shane explores the early life of Herman Web...

Episode page
April 6, 2022

The Bizarre Case of Mitrice Richardson

This is a single non-series episode. In 2009, a young woman walked out from a Lost Hills Police Station in the middle of the night and disappeared without a trace. Today, over a decade later, the case of Mitrice Richardson …

Episode page
March 30, 2022

Kristie and Kahlil

This is a single non-series episode. Today’s story is one of lust, despair, illusions, and an unbridled affinity for putting up deceptive fronts. Today, we talk about Kristie Evans. Our story begins sometime around 1974 in Ro...

Episode page
March 16, 2022

Ann and Anthony Anastasi

A seemingly happy family belonging in a Norman Rockwell painting would soon turn into a thing of nightmares… this is the story of Ann and Anthony Anastasi, it's one of jealousy, rage, and murder. Ann Marie Anastasi was born s...

Episode page
March 15, 2022

S2 Ep80: Unsolved Murder of Sister Cathy [Safe in Socks]

Shane and Gemma continue the conversation on the unsolved murder of Sister Cathy. The pair interview Teresa Lancaster and her daughter Annette to discuss Teresa's new book Safe in Socks. Visit us online at: Itsfoulplay.com Su...

Episode page
March 11, 2022

High School Podcast : Murderous Soul

A few months ago, Shane received an email from a high school teacher in Hartwell, Georgia, named Leanne. Leanne explained that she was using true crime to teach a Freshman and Sophomore course in World Literature in a very ou...

Episode page
March 2, 2022

S7 Ep3: Suffolk Strangler

(Part 3) In late 2006 a small town in the East of the United Kingdom was shaken by a killing spree of 5 women, over a very short 6 week period. Ipswich, a tranquil, historic town in the county of …

Episode page
Feb. 16, 2022

S7 Ep2: Suffolk Strangler

(Part 2) In late 2006 a small town in the East of the United Kingdom was shaken by a killing spree of 5 women, over a very short 6 week period. Ipswich, a tranquil, historic town in the county of …

Episode page
Feb. 2, 2022

S7 Ep1: Suffolk Strangler

(Part 1) In late 2006 a small town in the East of the United Kingdom was shaken by a killing spree of 5 women, over a very short 6 week period. Ipswich, a tranquil, historic town in the county of …

Episode page
Jan. 19, 2022

David Early

This is a single non-series episode. People tend to stick with what they know. If you've been a criminal for the majority of your life, it can be difficult to envision another way of living. While it's true some former …

Episode page
Jan. 12, 2022

Robert Kissel

This is a single non-series episode. Nancy and Robert Kissel had a life that would exceed most people's wildest dreams. A luxury apartment in a serene setting just a stone's throw from Hong Kong. A spacious vacation home in r...

Episode page
Dec. 29, 2021

Papin Sisters

This is a single non-series episode. While you may have never heard of the Papin sisters, their story may sound familiar: two domestic servants seeking revenge on their wealthy employer for the cards they’ve been dealt in lif...

Episode page
Dec. 22, 2021

Christmas Episode 3 - Maurin Murders

Longview Washington, Friday 20 December 1985, The Daily News, lead with the headline ‘Congress bogs down in battle to cut federal deficit’. The front page was filled with stories about property tax increases, economic growth,...

Episode page
Dec. 15, 2021

Christmas Episode 2 - Sodder Family

For almost 40 years there stood a huge billboard on route 19 near Fayatteville, West Virginia. It showed the images of 5 children and the following inscription ‘On Christmas Eve 1945 our home was set afire and five of our …

Episode page
Dec. 8, 2021

Christmas Episode 1 - Italian Hall

Michigan’s Northern Peninsula was rife copper mining country. This was big business, making huge profits for the mining companies, but giving little pay and benefits to their workers. Many of the workers were immigrants, who ...

Episode page
Dec. 1, 2021

Ruthie McCoy

This is a single non-series episode. In the 1992 horror cult-classic film Candyman, curiosity takes a grad student places she never thought she’d find herself. Our lead, Helen Lyle, played by Virginia Madsen, is a young white...

Episode page
Nov. 10, 2021

Rubin 'Hurricane' Carter

This is a single non-series episode. For some people, attempts made to rise above the hand they’ve been dealt are met with success. Other people strive to better themselves and encounter notable resistance - maybe even a sens...

Episode page