Welcome to our new website!

Episodes

Dec. 15, 2021

Christmas Episode 2 - Sodder Family

For almost 40 years there stood a huge billboard on route 19 near Fayatteville, West Virginia. It showed the images of 5 children…

Episode page
Dec. 8, 2021

Christmas Episode 1 - Italian Hall

Michigan’s Northern Peninsula was rife copper mining country. This was big business, making huge profits for the mining companies…

Episode page
Dec. 1, 2021

Ruthie McCoy

This is a single non-series episode. In the 1992 horror cult-classic film Candyman, curiosity takes a grad student places she nev…

Episode page
Nov. 10, 2021

Rubin 'Hurricane' Carter

This is a single non-series episode. For some people, attempts made to rise above the hand they’ve been dealt are met with succes…

Episode page
Nov. 3, 2021

S2 Ep79: Unsolved Murder of Sister Cathy [The Brother]

Shane and Gemma continue the conversation on the unsolved murder of Sister Cathy. The pair interview “the brother” who shares his…

Episode page
Oct. 20, 2021

The Story of Lana Clayton

This is a standalone episode. The act of taking someone’s life through poisoning has been around since Ancient Rome and Greece, w…

Episode page
Oct. 14, 2021

St Valentine's Day Massacre

This is a standalone episode. When seven men were gunned down in a Chicago garage in 1929, their killers thought nothing of it. A…

Episode page
Oct. 6, 2021

S6 Ep9: Throwaways

Season Finale. For three years now I’ve been nailing these little red crosses into the ground. I know it doesn’t mean very much, …

Episode page
Sept. 23, 2021

S6 Ep8: Throwaways

The best imaginable alibi, outside of lunch with the Dalai Lama, is simply to place yourself in police custody at the time the cr…

Episode page
Sept. 15, 2021

S6 Ep7: Throwaways

[Part 7] By the time someone becomes a lot lizard, they have, by and large, already suffered enough. Truck stop sex work is a lat…

Episode page
Sept. 8, 2021

S6 Ep6: Throwaways

Rather than adoring and desiring his mother according to the Freudian complex, Jerry Johns appears to have hated her subtly and r…

Episode page
Aug. 25, 2021

S6 Ep5: Throwaways

In pitch darkness, shortly after 2AM, Jane Doe #7 stumbled into the median of I-40, near Junction 58, in Kingston, Tennessee. The…

Episode page
Aug. 11, 2021

S6 Ep4: Throwaways

[Part 4] When you were in school you probably had class projects. You made terrariums and did that thing with a papier-mâché volc…

Episode page
July 21, 2021

S6 Ep3: Throwaways

[Part 3] After Shane started researching the case of the Barbourville Jane Doe, and sharing this story on Foul Play, smaller news…

Episode page
July 14, 2021

S6 Ep2: Throwaways

“Lot lizards” - that’s what they call them. The kind of prostitutes who work truck stops and trailer parks. These are not the hig…

Episode page
June 16, 2021

S6 Ep1: Throwaways

This new series details the investigation of the Redhead Murders, including details of how Shane got involved all the way to iden…

Episode page
June 9, 2021

S2 Ep78: Unsolved Murder of Sister Cathy [Richter's Medical Assistant…

Gemma and Shane interview Richter's Medical Assistant, who shares details from her time working for Dr. Christian Richter. You m…

Episode page
June 2, 2021

S2 Ep77: Unsolved Murder of Sister Cathy [Pam Conyers Connection?]

Shane and Gemma discuss the unsolved murder of Pamela Lynn Conyers with Pam's niece Ingrid. Detectives believe Pamela's murder ma…

Episode page
May 28, 2021

S8 Ep2: Unsolved Murder of Beverly Jarosz

(Part 2) I’ve been receiving requests from some of you to release the three podcasts I created years ago on the 1964 unsolved mur…

Episode page
May 28, 2021

S8 Ep3: Unsolved Murder of Beverly Jarosz

(Part 3) I’ve been receiving requests from some of you to release the three podcasts I created years ago on the 1964 unsolved mur…

Episode page
May 28, 2021

S8 Ep1: Unsolved Murder of Beverly Jarosz

(Part 1) I’ve been receiving requests from some of you to release the three podcasts I created years ago on the 1964 unsolved mur…

Episode page
May 26, 2021

S2 Ep76: Unsolved Murder of Sister Cathy (part 2) [LIVE w/Gemma and S…

(Part 2) Shane and Gemma did their first LIVE on-the-air podcast, take a listen as they answer questions and clarify a few things…

Episode page
May 19, 2021

S2 Ep75: Unsolved Murder of Sister Cathy (Part 1) [LIVE w/Gemma and S…

(Part 1) Shane and Gemma did their first LIVE on-the-air podcast, take a listen as they answer questions and clarify a few things…

Episode page
May 12, 2021

S2 Ep74: Unsolved Murder of Sister Cathy [Who was Russell Phillips?]

Shane and Gemma Hoskins from Netflix's The Keepers sit down with a former student and friend of Sister Russell's to discuss some …

Episode page