Welcome to our new website!

Episodes

April 24, 2019

S2 Ep30: Unsolved Murder of Sister Cathy [Cemetery Dig]

In Maryland Shane and Gemma sit down to discuss the Cemetery dig that uncovered a large room-sized hole in the ground that Fr Mas…

Episode page
April 17, 2019

S2 Ep29: Unsolved Murder of Sister Cathy [The Timeline] Part 2

Shane and Gemma sit down in Gemma's kitchen to discuss the entirety of the timeline surrounding Sister Cathy's case. From the lif…

Episode page
April 10, 2019

S2 Ep28: Unsolved Murder of Sister Cathy [The Timeline] Part 1

Shane and Gemma sit down in Gemma's kitchen to discuss the entirety of the timeline surrounding Sister Cathy's case. From the lif…

Episode page
April 3, 2019

S2 Ep27: Unsolved Murder of Sister Cathy [LIVE in Maryland with Teres…

Shane travels to the Baltimore area for a week - recording many episodes including this one in Greenbelt, MD with Survivor Teresa…

Episode page
March 27, 2019

S2 Ep26: Unsolved Murder of Sister Cathy [Q&A with Gemma and Shane] P…

PART 2: Gemma and Shane discuss the case, as well as answer questions that listeners have sent in.

Episode page
March 20, 2019

S2 Ep25: Unsolved Murder of Sister Cathy [Q&A with Gemma and Shane] P…

Gemma and Shane discuss the case, as well as answer questions that listeners have sent in. Are you obsessed with true crime and r…

Episode page
March 13, 2019

S2 Ep24: Unsolved Murder of Sister Cathy [Maskell's Confidential Stud…

This is part 2 of our discussion with Lil. Are you obsessed with true crime and rotten people? If you have a favorite murder and …

Episode page
Feb. 27, 2019

S2 Ep23: Unsolved Murder of Sister Cathy [Maskell's Confidential Stud…

Around the same time Sister Cathy went missing in 1969, Father Maskell started looking for a confidential secretary. Student Lil …

Episode page
Feb. 20, 2019

S2 Ep22: Unsolved Murder of Sister Cathy [1975 Maskell Abuse Reported]

In last week’s interview with Sean Caine from the Archdiocese of Baltimore - one of the subjects we discussed was when abuse alle…

Episode page
Feb. 13, 2019

S2 Ep21: Unsolved Murder of Sister Cathy [Interview with the Archdioc…

Part 2: The following interview is with the Vice-Chancellor of the Archdiocese of Baltimore. We will release this interview in tw…

Episode page
Feb. 6, 2019

S2 Ep20: Unsolved Murder of Sister Cathy [Interview with the Archdioc…

Part 1: The following interview is with the Vice-Chancellor of the Archdiocese of Baltimore. We will release this interview in tw…

Episode page
Jan. 30, 2019

S2 Ep19: Unsolved Murder of Sister Cathy [Bombshell - The Man in the …

Part 2: We continue our conversation with Sharon Bush - she explained she was present in the apartment shortly before Sister Cath…

Episode page
Jan. 23, 2019

S2 Ep18: Unsolved Murder of Sister Cathy [Bombshell - The Man in the …

Part 1: I’ve seen it before, a cold case stays unsolved until someone comes forward with information they thought was unimportant…

Episode page
Jan. 16, 2019

S2 Ep17: Unsolved Murder of Sister Cathy [The Keepers with Ryan White…

Part 2: Joining Gemma and Shane for a two-part episode in our series on the unsolved murder of Sister Cathy Cesnik is Ryan White …

Episode page
Jan. 9, 2019

S2 Ep16: Unsolved Murder of Sister Cathy [The Keepers with Ryan White…

Joining Gemma and Shane for a two part episode in our series on the unsolved murder of Sister Cathy Cesnik is Ryan White and Jean…

Episode page
Dec. 22, 2018

S2 Ep15: Unsolved Murder of Sister Cathy [Behind the Mic]

This special episode features hosts Shane and Gemma discussing the details that have led them here. We will return on January 8th…

Episode page
Dec. 19, 2018

S2 Ep14: Unsolved Murder of Sister Cathy [You Never Know]

This episode is dedicated to teachers and their students. Teachers, stay vigilant because you never know. Are you obsessed with t…

Episode page
Dec. 12, 2018

S2 Ep13: Unsolved Murder of Sister Cathy [Teachers and Friends]

This week’s guest has a unique insight into both Cathy and Russell’s personalities. They were her teachers, and later her friends…

Episode page
Dec. 5, 2018

S2 Ep12: Unsolved Murder of Sister Cathy [Good Joe, Bad Joe]

Dr. Lee Richmond was a professor of Education at Loyola University Maryland in the area of school counseling. She is a licensed p…

Episode page
Nov. 28, 2018

S2 Ep11: Unsolved Murder of Sister Cathy [If only they had listened]

Please be advised this episode contains content and language that is graphic in nature, listener discretion is strongly advised. …

Episode page
Nov. 21, 2018

S2 Ep10: Unsolved Murder of Sister Cathy [Q&A]

This special episode consists of Gemma and Shane answering questions many listeners have sent in about this case. We have several…

Episode page
Nov. 14, 2018

S2 Ep9: Unsolved Murder of Sister Cathy, Part 9 [Shady Business]

Podcaster Brooke Gittings joins us to discuss her knowledge of the assistant state attorney Sharon May. This is an episode you do…

Episode page
Nov. 7, 2018

S2 Ep8: Unsolved Murder of Sister Cathy [Coincidence]

Sharon’s uncle Billy happens to live in the apartment complex, granting him access to always being able to know when Cathy enters…

Episode page
Oct. 31, 2018

S2 Ep7: Unsolved Murder of Sister Cathy [Jane Roe]

Although several victims of Father Maskell came forward in the 90s, Sharon May at the prosecuting office refused to go forward wi…

Episode page